Blog post
tagged Books

Publishing too much

I came across a blog entry, How Often Should You Publish? by a published author, I'd like to comment on. Of course I'm speaking from a reader's perspective.

The idea that the publishing speed should be right for the fanbase I can see - say, I stopped reading Sluggy Freelance because there was too much too fast being added to for me, but obviously it's great for enough other people to make it a really popular webcomic.

But as he says in his key assertion, "you don't publish unless it's good", there is objectively publishing too much. My "favourite" example is Wolfgang Hohlbein, a German fantasy author who seems to publish 7 or more books a year. The problem is that the quality suffers. To avoid anything that may have to do with taste, here are some examples.
In one book hailed as "his most ambitious novel", one of the secondary characters for a few chapters is incorrectly referred to by the name of an entirely different character that died in the prequel. Offhand I remember one other scene which didn't make sense until I figured out in one sentence he'd used the wrong name of the two characters involved.
Another was a six-part series, and at the end of one book one of the characters was catatonic, and the rhetoric of the other sounded like getting him out of it was the big quest-thing for the next volume, but at the start of that next book the poor sod was just a bit under the weather.
His last book that I gave a chance on one page said "she ran towards the forest, where she could get away since she knew every single tree", and five pages later "she had never entered the forest, only walked along its edge".

Re-reading and editing a manuscript before sending it to a publisher certainly is a good idea, even if it takes time.

Turning back to webcomics, the fun part is that there (among amateurs, of course), one piece of advice is to start your first project even if your art and all sucks, because the practise will help you get better, and not doing it means you probably won't get better.

I should take that to heart.

Blog tags: Reading Thoughts

Comments

Sure, go ahead! :)

Hey!
Was just wondering if it would be OK for you if I'd link to this entry. I'll (at some point in the next future) write an entry on my blog about things I like and dislike when reading and your example on how an author can turn off readers and especially me is just so great... (Never managed to read one of Holbeins books myself, so I can't come up with something alike).
If no, than no - no offense taken.
Greets,
pax

[...] Sloppy writing and inconsistencies. For instance saying outright and showing through multiple examples throughout the book that technology stops working or breaks as soon as anything magic comes near, but having a major magic ritual accompanied by background music from a CD player. Writing like Wolfgang Hohlbein. [...]

I don't know. I suspect that both on his and his publishes' side there may be some "he's a big name, so people will buy the books, anyway" involved. *sigh*

On the other hand, that's what a good editor is for. Those books should never have made it to press with such glaring continuity errors.

I wonder if he's like Anne Rice and fired his editor because he didn't like what they said...